In partnership with
For decades, the Caribbean has been the go-to playground for divers: easy flights, warm water, forgiving conditions, and legendary reefs. Places like Bonaire, Cozumel, and the Cayman Islands earned their reputations for a reason.
But something’s changing.
More divers. More cruise ships. More pressure on reefs that were never designed for this kind of traffic.
And quietly — almost without announcing it — experienced divers are starting to look elsewhere.
This isn’t about abandoning the Caribbean. It’s about expanding your mental dive map.
Below are five underrated reef destinations that seasoned divers are increasingly choosing instead — places with healthier reefs, fewer crowds, and the kind of dives that remind you why you fell in love with scuba in the first place.
1. Dominica — The Caribbean Before the Crowds
Dominica doesn’t advertise itself loudly — and that’s exactly the point.
Often confused with the Dominican Republic (they’re very different), Dominica is wild, volcanic, and refreshingly undeveloped. There are no mega-resorts. No cruise-ship swarms clogging the docks daily. Just steep jungle, black-sand beaches, and dramatic underwater topography.
Why divers are switching
Sheer walls that drop fast into deep blue
Consistently low diver traffic
One of the best places in the Caribbean for whales, including sperm whales
What you’ll see
Sponges the size of small cars
Seahorses, frogfish, and flying gurnards
Volcanic vents and dramatic lava formations
Who it’s best for
Intermediate divers who like walls and depth
Divers who value quiet over nightlife
Who it’s not for
Anyone looking for resort-style diving or nightlife scenes
2. Saba — Proof That Protection Works
Saba is tiny. You won’t find beaches. You won’t find big hotels.
What you will find is one of the best-protected marine parks in the Caribbean — and it shows.
Fishing restrictions, strict mooring rules, and decades of conservation have created reefs that feel almost untouched compared to their neighbors.
Why divers are switching
Pristine coral health
Minimal diver numbers
Exceptional visibility year-round
What you’ll see
Healthy hard corals (increasingly rare)
Reef sharks, turtles, and schooling fish
Lava pinnacles rising from deep water
Who it’s best for
Experienced divers
Photographers chasing clean, uncluttered scenes
Who it’s not for
Brand-new divers uncomfortable with deeper profiles
3. Providencia, Colombia — The Caribbean’s Best Kept Secret
Providencia feels like the Caribbean 20 years ago.
Technically part of Colombia, this small island sits far off the mainland and sees only a trickle of divers each year. That isolation has protected its reefs — and kept mass tourism at bay.
Why divers are switching
Low diver density
Healthy reef structure
Authentic island culture (not tourism-first)
What you’ll see
Massive barrel sponges
Eagle rays and reef sharks
Coral formations that feel old
Who it’s best for
Divers who want culture + diving
Travelers comfortable with a little logistical effort
Who it’s not for
Anyone who wants ultra-polished dive operations
4. Tobago — Where the Atlantic Brings the Big Stuff
Tobago doesn’t get nearly the attention it deserves.
Positioned where the Atlantic meets the Caribbean, Tobago gets stronger currents, which means one thing: nutrients — and nutrients bring life.
Why divers are switching
Bigger animals
Cooler, clearer water at times
Less bleaching pressure than calmer reefs
What you’ll see
Massive brain corals
Nurse sharks and eagle rays
Schools of jacks and snapper
Who it’s best for
Divers comfortable with mild current
Anyone chasing “more fish, less people”
Adventure outside the ordinary
What happens when one of the most trusted specialty outdoor retailers, REI Co-op, teams up with the world's largest travel company, Intrepid Travel? You get a unique collection of active trips that offer meaningful, immersive travel experiences in the outdoors.
It’s travel inspired by REI, operated by Intrepid. Think community farm stays in Costa Rica, camping in Joshua Tree’s wild backcountry, cycling in Peru’s Sacred Valley, or sleeping in mountain huts before summiting Mount Kilimanjaro.
So, where will you go? Explore more than 85 destinations worldwide with a small group of up to 16, and an expert local leader who’ll help you to truly experience the destination.
REI Co-op members save 15% on REI Exclusive trips and receive a 20% off coupon to use at REI Co-op after booking REI Recommended trips.
For T&Cs and to view the full collection of trips in 85+ destinations, visit rei.com/travel.
5. Turneffe Atoll, Belize — Go Where the Boats Don’t
Ambergris Caye gets the headlines. Turneffe Atoll gets the reefs.
As the largest atoll in the Western Hemisphere, Turneffe offers sprawling reef systems far from the daily churn of shore-based dive boats.
Why divers are switching
Fewer boats
Strong conservation protections
Massive reef coverage
What you’ll see
Sharks, rays, turtles
Healthier coral than many mainland sites
Night dives that feel electric
Who it’s best for
Liveaboard divers
Anyone prioritizing reef quality over convenience
Final Thought
The Caribbean isn’t ruined. Not even close.
But the best diving now rewards effort — the willingness to look past the obvious names and follow the reefs that are still breathing easy.
If you’ve been feeling that itch for quieter dives, this might be your sign.
Next week, we’re going to talk about something else divers are noticing underwater… the weird stuff is coming back.
